Guest blog: ICANN needs to follow its own bylaws on UDRP review

Guest blog by Shawn Gunnarson

That ICANN too often winks at its fundamental rules is illustrated by the Preliminary GNSO Issue Report on the Current State of the Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (“UDRP Report”). At a basic level, the UDRP Report is untimely and unresponsive. It satisfies neither the timeline prescribed by the bylaws nor the substantive criteria of an issue report required by the bylaws. Rather than assisting the GNSO Council, the Report appears to dismiss the Council’s questions and concerns and presents a one-sided advocacy brief against conducting a Policy Development Process (PDP). This it does despite the barely acknowledged unanimous support for a PDP on the UDRP expressed by the Council, and two working groups.

Is the U.S. turning its back on innovation in Internet governance?

With its Further Notice of Inquiry (FNOI) on the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) contract, the U.S. Commerce Department
has signaled its increasing dissatisfaction with ICANN's nongovernmental global governance model. NTIA has gone out of its way to rebuff the idea of a transition to a fully denationalized regime. The idea of globalizing this aspect of Internet governance through a private sector nonprofit that governs by contract was embodied in the 1998 White Paper that led to the creation of ICANN. That idea is still promoted by ICANN itself, the Internet Society and luminaries such as Vint Cerf. But the Commerce Department is having none of it. The explanation for this seems to be conservatism. Not the Christian-evangelist nationalist conservatism of the U.S. Republican Party, but conservatism in the old-fashioned, generic sense: inertia – a lack of willingness to spend the extra energy it takes to do things in new and unfamiliar ways. The Commerce Department, and many others in Washington, are palpably weary of ICANN. This retreat to nationalism runs throughout the FNOI.

The sad performance of the European Commission in ICANN

The EU needs new and better representation in ICANN. Its operatives in the Governmental Advisory Committee (GAC) are failing to uphold European values related to free expression, open internet and bottom up governance. EC representatives in ICANN are utterly devoid of any vision of what kind of policies they want or what values they wish to uphold. The EC seems interested only in more power for itself – even though it has no clear idea what it wants to do with that power. So it has locked itself into a reactionary position. It is turning its back on bottom up, multistakeholder governance and, amazingly, it is appealing to the United States to exert unilateral authority over ICANN in order to pursue its apparent goal of a governmental takeover of ICANN. It is a sorry spectacle. Evidence for those strong conclusions can be found in Commissioner Nellie Kroes' recent letters and speeches.

ICANN’s new “Chief Security Officer”

Jeff Moss is famous in the security community as the founder of DEF CON and Black Hat. He is in Internet governance news today because ICANN has just hired him as its new “Chief Security Officer.” The corporation has issued a self-congratulatory news release, prepared by its London public relations firm, in which various prominent people effusively praise the hire. We offer up our own observations and a cautionary note.

ARIN sets new speed record for policy making

It's racing season, and not just for cars. Some people have accused ARIN of not following its specified transfer policy in its handling of the Nortel-Microsoft IPv4 address trade. But the complainers are just not up to speed. With a few strokes of the keyboard, ARIN has brought its transfer policy into alignment with what's really going on in the world.

ARIN stumbles into the Nortel-Microsoft IP address deal

Something extraordinary happened today in the Internet economy. It is now official: legacy IPv4 address holders – that is, organizations and companies who received their IP addresses before ARIN existed and are not under one of its Registration Services Agreement contracts – have property rights in their v4 address blocks. They can sell them to whoever they like. And the institution that insists that no such property rights can ever exist – the American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN) has been incorporated into an agreement that legally ratifies this.

ARIN says “No!” to competing registries, independence of legacy space holders

While last week's IG news was dominated by the ICANN meeting in San Francisco, including the Board's watershed moment approving .xxx, other important IG decisions were occurring elsewhere. In accordance with the ARIN Policy Development Process (PDP), the ARIN Advisory Council (AC) held a meeting on 17 March 2011, deciding on some important policy debates we've recently covered. All of the proposals focus on the relationship between legacy space holders and ARIN.  While abandoning the proposals short circuits any attempt to arrive at mutually agreed upon policy, the AC's actions certainly clarifies the position of ARIN.

ICANN San Francisco: MuSH, GAC, MuSH!

The San Francisco ICANN meeting has been completely dominated by GAC-Board negotiations over the new top level domain program. The underlying theme of those negotiations is the role of nation-states in the governance of Internet names and addresses. In the past few days I’ve learned a lot about the perspectives of various parties on this standoff, including people in civil society, the At Large Advisory Committee and the Noncommercial Users Constituency, business people, trademark lawyers, and government officials.
I come away more convinced than ever that we are not getting it right, this relationship between traditional nation-states and ICANN. At the same time, I see that most people involved, especially governments, fail to grasp that. The answer is not, as everyone seems to assume, more discussions and negotiations. The collisions that took place in Brussels last month will be replayed endlessly unless we diagnose the problem better.

Upcoming Event: “NCUC@ICANN: Internet Governance and the Global Public Interest”

Public Interest Groups to Discuss Controversial Plans to Add New Domains at San Francisco ICANN Meeting Pre-Event

craigslist Founder Craig Newmark to Keynote Internet Policy Conference

(San Francisco)  ICANN’s Non-Commercial Users Constituency (NCUC) is pleased to host a policy conference “NCUC@ICANN: Internet Governance and the Global Public Interest”on Friday 11 March 2011 at the Westin St. Francis Hotel at Union Square in San Francisco.

The all-day civil society policy conference will be held immediately before the 40th International ICANN Meeting and is targeted at international Internet governance participants, as well as Bay Area law and policy experts, digital rights activists and other civil society actors concerned with Internet governance policies.

Panelists will explore a number of Internet policy issues in which NCUC is engaged, including panel discussions on censorship, privacy, intellectual property rights and domain name take-downs. The conference will also examine the appropriate role for national governments vis-à-vis other stakeholders in Internet governance, and consider ICANN’s ability to address the concerns of developing countries and serve the global public interest.