On July 30 a majority of the ICANN Board took a fateful step away from open public participation in domain name policy making. In a decision that seriously impairs ICANN’s claim to be a multi-stakeholder, bottom up institution, the Board voted 10-4 to impose upon civil society groups a charter that they did not support and which is designed to weaken and fragment their participation.
The Board-approved charter for a Non Commercial Stakeholders Group (NCSG) was drafted directly by ICANN’s staff, without any consultations with the affected noncommercial organizations. When it was put up for public comment the reaction was overwhelmingly negative. And yet the majority of the Board (with several strong dissents, see the “silver lining” below) didn’t care, and passively complied with the direction fed to it by its Vice Chair and staff. The staff did not make a single modification reflecting the views of the overwhelming majority of the affected community.
The importance of this issue goes well beyond the NCSG; it relates to the whole problem of public participation in ICANN. Is ICANN a structure to facilitate policy making by any interested and affected stakeholder, or is ICANN nothing more than a self-perpetuating corporation that sees the public as a potential threat and public participation as something to be carefully managed and controlled?