The 3rd meeting of the UN Internet Governance Forum is now underway in Hyderabad, India, beginning with the Annual Symposium of GigaNet (Global Internet Governance Academic Network). Attendance has been affected by the violence in Mumbai, which is 700 km away. Life in Hyderabad, however, is quite normal, attendees are moving about the city and the suburban “Cyberabad” area where the Forum is being held with no problems, other than the sometimes horrific road traffic. The presence of Indian security forces at the hotels and conference venues is noticeable. Many Indian commentators take the same attitude toward avoidance as was taken by New Yorkers after 9/11: it is important to not be intimidated and to insist on going on with one’s life.
New Publication and Website: Appraising the Success of the IGF
Touré’s ITU still pushing for an Internet counter-revolution
The speech by the International Telecommunication Union’s Hamadoun Touré brought the ongoing power struggle over Internet governance into the open. Toure spoke openly of the ongoing “war” between ICANN and the ITU. He demanded a stronger role for governments in ICANN, dismissing ICANN’s Governmental Advisory Committee (GAC) as “cosmetic” (quite wrong, as I will show later). He correctly accused the UN Internet Governance Forum of “avoiding issues” but also rather harshly dismissed it as a “waste of time.” I commend Secretary General Touré for his forthrightness, which is all too rare in international organizations. Unfortunately, his blunt speech supports the wrong cause.
Let me be blunt, too. Mr. Secretary-General, this is all about competition for power, isn’t it? Your international organization lost a lot of authority over the communications industry when the Internet emerged, and now you are trying to get some of it back. The same goes for the governments who constitute the GAC. And of course, for the U.S. government, it’s all about holding on to the special powers it got because of its historical control over the contractors who ran the early internet. Why should internet users and civil society care about your demands?
The New Global Name Grab in Cairo
ICANN's policy for adding new generic TLDs was (sort of) settled in June. Now the staff has come up with a 200-page implementation plan that is being circulated at the Cairo meeting and online. The plan will clearly have to be modified; it is generating massive discontent and controversy.
ICANN web site is blocked in Egypt
Economic analysis of Registry-registrar integration
From the ICANN does good department, ICANN has released a report by Charles Rivers Associates on the economic relationship between registries and registrars. All in all the report takes a fairly cautious approach to its recommendations and its main benefits lie in the introduction of more rigorous economic analysis into the ICANN policy dialogue. In the full post, we summarize the recommendations, and will review the whole report in greater detail and report anything of note later.
Bulgarian Group Challenges ICANN's restriction of IDNs to Governments
Privacy by design?
I just returned from the “Internet of Things, Internet of the Future” conference sponsored by the French Presidency of the EU. At a panel on the privacy implications of RFID, I was struck by the way so many panelists, perhaps 4 or 5 out of 7, invoked “privacy by design” as a way of responding to RFID privacy threats. They all seemed to agree that it was somehow possible to pre-configure the technology in a way that privacy is structurally protected. Appropriately enough, the next day one of the chief intellectual promoters of this myth, law professor Lawrence Lessig, keynoted the conference.
I think people who put such stock in the ability of “design” or constructed “architectures” to solve or forestall social problems are wrong. Our ability to solve privacy problems depends on how strongly people value privacy, how well they mobilize politically and economically and whether they have the legal and regulatory tools to intervene in strategic areas of the value chain. There is no magic shortcut that allows a social objective to be inserted into the “genes” of a technology at the outset to save us from all that laborious work.
Commerce Department asks the world to comment on its plans to retain control of the root
IGP Fellowships to Hyderabad awarded
The Internet Governance Project has awarded two fellowships to young scholars from Poland and China to enable them to attend the Hyderabad Internet Governance Forum and present their research at the 3rd annual Symposium of GigaNet (the Global Internet Governance Academic Network). Dr. Joanna Kulesza, of the University of Lodz Faculty of Law and Administration, will present a paper titled “Internet governance and the jurisdiction of states.” Dr. Zhuo Zhang, of the Wuhan University School of Journalism and Communication, China, will present her paper (co-authored with Handong Wang): “Two Kinds of Violence: Internet Governance and Internet Mob in Mainland China.”