Reforming ICANN Oversight: A Historic Opportunity

IGP today responded to a U.S. Department of Commerce proceeding seeking comment on the future of its political oversight over ICANN. The proceeding is part of a mid-term review of ICANN's 3-year Joint Project Agreement (JPA) with U.S. Commerce Department NTIA.

In a move that is likely to attract attention and debate we called for ICANN and the IGF to forge an agreement to institute a bi-annual review and public consultation concerning ICANN’s record and accountability. These ideas will be raised both at the U.S. Commerce Department public meeting February 28 and at the public consultation of the U.N. Internet Governance Forum in Geneva February 26.

2.2008 Comments of the Internet Governance Project: (Docket No. 071023616-7617-01) The Continued Transition of the Technical Coordination and Management of the Internet’s Domain Name and Addressing System: Midterm Review of the Joint Project Agreement

[Abstract] Suggested citation: Comments of the Internet Governance Project: (Docket No. 071023616-7617-01) The Continued Transition of the Technical Coordination and Management of the Internet's Domain Name and Addressing System: Midterm Review of the Joint Project Agreement (February 15, 2008). Internet Governance Project. Paper IGP08-001. Available at https://www.internetgovernance.org/pdf/IGP-JPA-08-comments.pdf

Governments, ICANN and the JPA (part 2)

We were discussing how governments could take over ICANN. This was in response to a new meme gaining popularity within the Beltway: the idea that we need to retain the Commerce Department’s leash on ICANN (the JPA) because if we don’t, other governments (autocratic Russians, Chinese commie hordes, turbaned Islamo-fascists or languid, dirigiste Europeans) will somehow “interfere” with DNS.

But the future of the JPA has virtually nothing to do with ICANN’s subordination to other governments. It's about ICANN's subordination to the US government. The people advancing this meme have not specified how a government takeover is supposed to happen, much less how retaining the JPA would prevent it. As I started to argue yesterday, it is hard to conceive of a single plausible scenario for governments to exert more power over ICANN that isn't either a) already happening, and being aided and abetted by the USG; b) more likely to happen the longer the US stays in control or c) require the US government’s consent.

To prove this point, here are some plausible scenarios and mechanisms through which national governments could put pressure on ICANN. By examining these, we can better appreciate just how far off base the CDT and others are.

The Future of ICANN (Again)

ICANN is lobbying hard to bring an end to its “Joint Project Agreement” (JPA) with the US Commerce Department. (The JPA is one of two tethers that ties ICANN to the US government.) Key ICANN management personnel are in Washington today and meetings are being held with industry stakeholder groups. Feelers are being sent out to other stakeholders.

ICANN’s Board Chairman, Peter Dengate Thrush, laid down a bold and clear position in his early filing of comments before the NTIA: “The JPA is no longer necessary. Concluding it is the next step in transition of the coordination of the Domain Name System (DNS) to the private sector. This step will provide continuing confidence that the original vision laid out in the White Paper is being delivered.” Although there is more to global Internet governance than ICANN, this issue deserves more attention than it seems to be getting.

The F Root Agreement: Formalized Informality

The root server agreement between ICANN and ISC was published yesterday. As “agreements” go, this is a good one — by which we mean, it reflects a peer relationship between ICANN and the root server operator and does no harm to the status quo, which is flexible and distributed. The contract, labelled a “Mutual Responsibilities Agreement” (MRA), constitutes a massive concession to distributed authority over the root server system. ICANN's Board should support it.

Overlapping Sets: From Rio to Delhi

The second Internet Governance Forum in Rio de Janeiro continued the slow but steady movement to clarify the critical Internet governance issues. The Forum discussed, for the first time, the initial issue that prompted the international focus on Internet governance, critical Internet resources. It also explored the other clusters that had been identified: openness, diversity, access and security and further refined these. But the main result, not as well noticed, is a growing recognition that the key issues have less to do with the clusters than with where they overlap and conflict.

An IG Research Home: A Long Term Role for IGF?

It is quickly becoming apparent that an important function of the UN's Internet Governance Forum could be to serve as a long term clearinghouse for knowledge acquisition and assessment concerning Internet governance. Despite its structural imperfections, the IGF is becoming a magnet for the academic community to discuss Internet governance ideas. As such, it may be finding its role in the global Internet governance regime.

Taking Stock of the Rio Internet Governance Forum

Reflection on what was wrong and what was right with the Rio Internet Governance Forum is not waiting for the February 25 “stocktaking” session planned by the IGF's Secretariat. Civil society advisory group member Adam Peake has already opened an interesting dialogue on the governance list. I have some opinions about that…

Too much of the energy of the Forum and its participants is being thrown away on issues that are not global in scope, and have nothing to do with global governance of the Internet. We all must pay closer attention to the distinction between issues that are best addressed at the national, local or regional levels and those that truly require global coordination and global institutions. IGF should be restricted to the global. If the truly global governance issues are actually quite narrow and specialized, and don't include the issues that turn you on, so be it. Those who are fundamentally not interested in those issues should find a more appropriate venue for their activities. The disappointing thing about IGF 2 was that the dialogue was so cluttered with things that do not require or will never get international coordination or agreement that it was impossible to focus on the things that do.